Skip to main content

Navigating the Stormy Weather of Google SERPs

April 6, 2020

Summary: I don’t think anybody in the SEO world is ready to claim they know what’s going on with Google and its SERPs, but we’re confident in saying the more closely we pay attention these things, the quicker and more prepared we’ll all be to act quickly and gain any available advantage.

While it might seem like a lifetime ago, back in January I wrote about Google’s move to de-clutter the first page of search results. And just 8 weeks later, we’ve seen Google make even more substantial updates that SEO pros should be watching intently.

To quickly recap, the clean-up we discussed two months ago aimed to streamline a searcher’s online experience by deduplicating search results. URLs in position zero with a featured snippet would no longer appear anywhere else on search engine results pages (SERPs) as they had previously. This update was great for users looking for a clean, organized experience; not-so-great for the marketers who’s URLs originally appeared twice on page one of the SERPs. 

Of course, Google’s updates are never ending: their algorithms will forever evolve alongside user behaviors. They tend to tweak their algorithm hundreds of times a year. Naturally, we keep a very close eye on the search landscape and – in keeping with the general turbulent tone of 2020 – it’s been kind of unstable. 

Let’s discuss what seems to have been a broad core search algorithm update and the significant fluctuations that caught the eye of SEOs everywhere. The sooner your business understands the changes, the sooner you can adapt, optimize and benefit from it. 

The Choppy Waters of the Search Landscape

About two weeks after Google’s big featured snippet update, SEOs noticed a significant disturbance in the Forc—oh wait, wrong Galaxy. What SEOs in our Galaxy noticed was drastic changes in Google’s rankings over the course of a 48 hour period. One SEO I know called it, “The biggest two days in SERP disturbances in the last two years.”


The above is a screenshot of the MozCast from January and February of this year. For those unfamiliar with the MozCast, here’s how Moz describes its tool:

“MozCast is an experiment in tracking the “weather” patterns of the Google algorithm. While big updates like Panda and Penguin get a lot of press, Google revealed that they made 516 changes in 2010, and all evidence suggests that pace has continued. What we notice is barely the tip of the iceberg. MozCast was designed to help you keep track of the day-to-day changes in the Google algorithm. An average day in the SERPs is about 70°F.”

In the screenshot, you can see that on February 7, the MozCast was 116°F. On February 8, the Mozcast was 115°F. Big algorithm changes means hot and stormy weather, and this is some of the hottest and stormiest weather we’ve seen in the search results in recent memory.

What does it mean? And what has Google said about the turbulent times on search engine pages to start the year?
Credit to StanVentures for helping get all of us the answers to these questions, which they wrote about here.


Google’s answer is coy, but we’re going to agree with Thekkethil here — it’s obvious something important is going on here.

Here’s a second screenshot of the MozCast, which I took on March 29th (it includes the previous 30 days).


The MozCast has remained at consistently turbulent temperatures throughout March, with most days clocking in well above that 70°F average. On March 18, the MozCast measured 103°F, and hit the century mark (100°F on the nose) a couple of days later on March 23.

I don’t think anybody in the SEO world is ready to claim they know what’s going on with Google and its SERPs, but we’re confident in saying the more closely we pay attention these things, the quicker and more prepared we’ll all be to act quickly and gain any available advantage.

What’s Happening With Position Zero?

So far we’ve established a couple of things: Google made sweeping changes to its featured snippet position and continued to make further significant tweaks to…we’re not exactly sure what.

Since we can only speculate on what else is causing such stormy waters on the SERP landscape, let’s talk about something we have at least a little data on: what’s been happening with “position zero” since all the featured snippet changes?

We’re going to reference two fantastic posts for this discussion: this one by Dr. Pete and this one by PJ Howland.Dr. Pete’s post is a great breakdown of the initial update, but we’re going to focus on the takeaways of Howland’s post, since it contains real data. Some of the key takeaway from that post were:

  • Longtime snippet winners are seeing CTR and traffic drops
  • When a double snippet is present, CTR on the first snippet tanks
  • There’s not a true number 1 spot
  • Evidence of CTR bumps below the fold
  • Clickability matters more than it ever has

The caveat here is there aren’t yet a lot of concrete, ironclad takeaways after just 30-60 days. What we do know is there is evidence to suggest some or all of these things might be true. If you hedge your bets and keep your ear to the ground, you may just be able to turn these story SERP conditions into a positive for your business.

As I’ve said a few times, the conditions in Google’s SERPs right now are rougher and more unpredictable than they’ve been in years. Which is not unlike the position we find ourselves in today – all around the globe. In both situations, there are two options: panic, and not handle things so well, resulting in a poor outcome for everybody. Or, take the situation as it comes, remain calm, and find a way to come out the other side stronger, smarter and more prepared to handle this type of scenario than ever before.

Stay safe out there in the world, and good luck out there on the SERPs!

WSI was founded in 1995 and is an innovative digital marketing agency with offices in over 80 countries. We’ve spent over 20 years helping more than 100,000 companies and large global brands unlock the full potential of their business by leveraging the Internet and its many unrecognized opportunities. We’d be happy to help do the same for you and consult on your digital marketing strategy.  Simply give me a call or email me at to learn more.

About the Author

Rick spent 20 years in the insurance industry in finance, primarily developing reporting platforms for B & C stakeholders.   His ability to speak to consumers of data (managers and analysts) and translate their needs to programmers led him to start his own digital marketing agency in 2004 to develop data driven solutions for business owners. 


The Best Digital Marketing Insight and Advice

The WSI Digital Marketing Blog is your go-to-place to get tips, tricks and best practices on all things digital marketing related. Check out our latest posts.

We are committed to protecting your privacy. For more info, please review our Privacy and Cookie Policies. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Don’t stop the learning now!

Here are some other blog posts you may be interested in.

Embracing AI for Business Transformation

Summary: Explore AI’s transformative power for businesses in today’s market with this podca…

Measuring Success: A Look Back at the Transition to GA4

Summary: In our latest blog post, we explore Google Analytics 4’s (GA4) transformative feat…

Global AI Survey Reveals New Opportunities for SMBs to Thrive

WSI, a global leader in digital marketing innovations, today unveiled the results of its 2024 AI…